Microwork Earnings beyond “Beermoney”

[Authored by Luisa Burchartz]

When people think of microwork in the EU, many think of it as a way of making some pocket money, “beermoney”, as a key Reddit page for microwork is also called. In this vision, workers can and do not rely on microwork earnings in their daily lives. This narrative, in which the role of microwork is downplayed, gives platforms power; pocket money is provided by family[i], not by employers. But how do microworkers think about their microwork earnings, and how do they actually use them? The following quote from an interview conducted as part of the Ghostwork project gives insight into the complexity behind microwork earnings. Emma, whose microwork earnings make up around a quarter of her rather small household income (10.000-20.000 euros/year), described the role of these earnings as follows:

Microworker Emma: “I literally use part of the [microwork] earnings for food, shoes, silly things like that (emphasis added). And then, at the same time, thanks to my mental health getting a bit better, I have improved so many things in my life, which also makes them more expensive. For example, I always wanted to be vegan because I think it’s a moral consistency issue for me.”

Interviewer: “So, microwork actually allows you to make those choices?”

Emma: “Yeah. Yeah. It does.”

Then, Emma uses microwork money for food, shoes, and morally consistent consumption. While she is making sense of them as “silly things”, it is also clear that they are important to her. Other microworkers, interviewed as part of the Ghostwork project, considered the earnings central for paying daily bills, while others reported using it as beer or coffee money. Based on a recently collected and still-ongoing survey (with a smaller set of 384 microworkers), I offer descriptive insights into how microworkers use and make sense of their earnings.

The first figure (Figure 1) shows substantial variation in the money use of microworkers. On the left, I depict whether microworkers use the earnings as part of their regular budget or whether they set it apart for specific spending purposes, “earmarking” in sociological terms[ii]. Overall, a similar percentage of microworkers use it as part of their regular budget (40%) and set it apart (42%), and 19% set some apart and use some as part of the regular budget. We also asked about spending in more depth (with non-exclusive categories[iii]), as visible on the right. Here, we see many different spending purposes that microworkers name. The two most common ways of spending it are “necessary or daily expenses” and “something extra for myself”[iv], as rather different ways of using the money. Another noteworthy observation: only 15% see it as “pocket money”.

 

Figure 1: Earmarking and Money Use of Microworkers

Note: Descriptive Statistics based on an ongoing survey with Microworkers, collected through Clickworker, in different EU countries, N=386.

 

Based on prior research[v], also from this project, we know there is substantial variation in the extent to which workers depend on microwork earnings. This raises the question of how income dependence is linked to spending practices. For income dependence, I look at four categories, ranging from (1) primary income as most dependent, to (2) essential but not primary, to (3) supplementary, and to (4) not considering it real income as the least dependent category[vi]. Figure 2 then shows earmarking practices and Figure 3 the different ways of using money across these groups.

Starting with earmarking: among those who consider it their primary income, more than half (59%) consider microwork earnings as part of the regular budget. In the least dependent group, namely microworkers who don’t see it as income, half earmark all the earnings, setting it apart for specific spendings. Here, only 30% consider it as part of the usual money. For supplementary and essential earners, this is more mixed.

 

Figure 2: Income Dependence and Earmarking

Note: Descriptive Statistics based on an ongoing survey with Microworkers, collected through Clickworker, in different EU countries, N=386.

 

When we look at the money use practices, differences become more prominent. In the most dependent group (upper right), more than half of the respondents (55%) use it for necessary expenses, and a substantial number use it to buy something extra for themselves (42%), or to save some money (37%). This already means that even those who are most dependent have rather different (or varied) ways of using the money. In the second-most dependent group, where earnings are essential but not primary, daily expenses, too, are the most common spending point. Amongst essential earners, spending microwork earnings on debt and credit card bills, too, is very prominent. In these two most dependent groups, the meaning of microwork money as pocket money is also rather absent. For the supplementers, using it for necessary/daily expenses and for something personal, extra are similarly common. Here, the use of the money seems rather diverse. Finally, for those who do not consider it income, using it for something personal is most common, and around a quarter do see it as pocket money. This group then seems to come closest to the “beer money” narrative.

 

Figure 3: Income Dependence and Money Use

Note: Descriptive Statistics based on an ongoing survey with Microworkers, collected through Clickworker, in different EU countries, N=386.

Microworkers’ usage and ways of thinking about the earnings then vary greatly. In fact, many use it for earnings they consider necessary and daily, or to buy something extra for themselves. Simultaneously, the percentage of microworkers who see it as pocket money is rather low. We can use these findings to think about EU microwork a bit differently: microworkers rely on the money in their daily lives, and often, they just consider it part of their usual budgets.

 

 

_______________________________________________________________________

[i] Historically, this often happened through women managing the household income. The term “beer money” was also used to designate the money wives would give their husbands as pocket money (Zelizer, 1997, The Social Meaning of Money. New York: Basic Books).

[ii] In The Social Meaning of Money, Zelizer (1997) argues that, while we tend to think of money as a neutral currency that is independent of human value (or corrupts it), the meanings people attribute to money are very much social. One way in which this happens is through earmarking: People set some money apart and give it special meaning. For instance, considering gifted money: the giver (and recipient) may want the recipient to spend it on something special rather than on groceries. Looking at Microwork earnings as beermoney is a similar way of setting it apart; it does not become part of the regular budget but is designated for a special use (beer). In this way, money can also have special (social) meanings for people.

[iii] Categories presented to microworkers are based on Jiang, L., Deng, X. N., & Wagner, C. (2024). Understanding the individual labor supply and wages on digital labor platforms: A microworker perspective. International Journal of Information Management, 79, 102823.

[iv] Interestingly, these two groups are rather exclusive: 35% of the sample does not spend it on either of the two purposes, 29% on necessary/daily items but not on something extra for oneself, 29% on something extra for oneself but not on necessary/daily items, and only 7% on both.

[v] E.g., Morgan, R. A., van Zoonen, W., & ter Hoeven, C. (2023). Lost in the crowd? An investigation into where microwork is conducted and classifying worker types. European journal of industrial relations, 29(3), 301-322.

[vi] Adapted categorisation based on: Schor, J. B., Attwood-Charles, W., Cansoy, M., Ladegaard, I., & Wengronowitz, R. (2020). Dependence and precarity in the platform economy. Theory and society, 49(5), 833-861.